Dr. Job Mogire · Cardiologist

The Mogire Contraindication Framework

Many breathwork guides never say when to stop, or who should not start. This framework is a cardiologist’s answer. Three gates name who should be careful, with which techniques, and why.

Most breathing techniques are safe for most people, and there are real exceptions. Go through the three gates before you choose a technique. If a gate applies to you, talk with your physician first. A gate is a reason for that conversation, not a reason for alarm.

Gate 1 of 3

Gate 1 · Absolute caution

Talk to your physician before starting any structured breathwork if you have:

  • A diagnosed arrhythmia (atrial fibrillation, SVT, ventricular arrhythmia)
  • Heart failure, any stage
  • Severe COPD or hypoxic respiratory failure
  • Epilepsy or a history of seizures (fast, deep breathing can trigger a seizure)
  • Pregnancy (avoid breath holds and extreme hyperventilation)
  • Active psychosis or a dissociative disorder
  • A recent cardiac event (heart attack, cardiac surgery, ablation) within six months

Gate 2 of 3

Gate 2 · Technique-specific caution

Wim Hof and hyperventilation methods

Never in or near water. Avoid in cardiovascular disease, pregnancy, and epilepsy.

Prolonged breath holds, over fifteen seconds

Avoid in hypertension, arrhythmia, and pregnancy.

High-volume cyclic hyperventilation (holotropic)

Avoid in cardiovascular disease, seizure disorders, severe anxiety, and trauma histories without clinical support.

If you take a beta-blocker

A beta-blocker lowers your resting heart rate, so your heart rate and HRV readings may not match what an app expects. Slow breathing can still be practised; trust how you feel over the numbers on the screen.

Gate 3 of 3

Gate 3 · Universal stop signs

For everyone, with every technique:

  • Stop if you feel chest pain, significant palpitations, or as though you might faint. Those symptoms need a physician.
  • Stop and breathe normally if you feel lightheaded or tingly. If the lightheadedness lasts beyond thirty seconds after you stop, the cause may be hyperventilation from incorrect technique, or an underlying condition.
  • Never use breathwork as a substitute for emergency care or for prescribed medication.

When your breath is calm, your own plans are still waiting

EYANA is part of House of Mastery. A slower breath can settle your body and help you think. Your own plans need more than a clear head. You finish what someone is waiting for. Nobody is waiting for your own plans.

Many things start the pattern. The pattern survives when your work has no structure. Keep your explanation. This page is about what finishes the pattern.

We give your own plans a date and someone who asks. Until you can give your own plans both yourself.

With that structure, your own plans move a little every week, and you stop carrying your plans alone.

Free, about two minutes, no email. Only you see your answers.

EYANA is health education, not medical advice. EYANA does not diagnose, treat, or replace your physician, and nothing here is a reason to start, stop, or change any medication or treatment. If you have a heart or lung condition, read the Mogire Contraindication Framework first and talk to your doctor. If you have chest pain, fainting, or a racing heart that will not settle, seek medical care.

Back to EYANA